Scoring sheet for papers #2

assignments/papers2/score.txt

-HW #1 Score:
+Paper Analysis #2 Score:
 
-XX / 10 : Submitted a PDF
+XX / 10 : Winstein et al. SIGCOMM
+
+XX / 10 : Wang et al. SIGCOMM
+
+XX / 10 : Mai et al. SIGCOMM
+
+For each evaluation, points are assigned as follows:
+    One point for each of the nine parts of the evaluation:
+        Answer shows careful consideration of the paper and the
+            question: 1 point
+        Answer shows a significant amount of consideration, but misses
+            important points: 0.5 points
+        Answer is cursory, or makes critical factual errors: 0.25 points
+        Not answered or unsatisfactory answer: 0 points
+    One additional point for overall critical analysis
+        Point is awarded for identifying both strengths and weaknesses
+            in the paper's evaluation
+
+For those that presented paper evaluations in class:
+    Ten points for the slides - five points each for:
+        Slides capture the most important points of the analysis
+        Slides are well-designed and clearly convey the information
+    Ten points for the presentation - five points each for:
+        Presenter covered the key points of the paper's evaluation
+            and his/her analysis of it
+        Presentation was clear, well-organized, and well-delivered
 
 ======
 Total score: XX / YY