Commit 29703093 authored by Robert Ricci's avatar Robert Ricci

Scoring update for 2015

parent e2b92456
Paper Analysis #1 Score: Paper Analysis #1 Score:
XX / 10 : Ravindranath et al. HotNets XX / 10 : Peter et al. OSDI
XX / 10 : Rhea et al. WORLDS XX / 10 : Lim et al. NSDI
XX / 10 : Sherwood et al. OSDI
For each evaluation, points are assigned as follows: For each evaluation, points are assigned as follows:
One point for each of the nine parts of the evaluation: One point for each of the eight parts of the evaluation:
Answer shows careful consideration of the paper and the Answer shows careful consideration of the paper and the
question: 1 point question: 1 point
Answer shows a significant amount of consideration, but misses Answer shows a significant amount of consideration, but misses
important points: 0.75 point important points: 0.75 point
Answer is cursory, or makes critical factual errors: 0.5 points Answer is cursory, or makes critical factual errors: 0.5 points
Not answered or unsatisfactory answer: 0 points Not answered or unsatisfactory answer: 0 points
One additional point for overall critical analysis Two additional points for overall critical analysis
Point is awarded for identifying both strengths and weaknesses Points awarded for identifying both strengths and weaknesses
in the paper's evaluation in the paper's evaluation
For those that presented paper evaluations in class: For those that presented paper evaluations in class:
......
Markdown is supported
0% or .
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment